Reviewer Guidelines | International Journal of Computing and Health Informatics

Thank you for agreeing to review for IJCHI. Your expertise helps maintain the high quality and integrity of our journal.

1

You receive an email invitation with the manuscript title and abstract. Accept or decline based on your expertise and availability.

2

If you accept, you will receive access to the full manuscript and review form through our online system.

3

Evaluate the manuscript based on the criteria below. Submit your review within 2-3 weeks.

4

Provide a clear recommendation: Accept, Minor Revisions, Major Revisions, or Reject.

Is the work novel and original? Does it contribute significantly to the field?

Is the research design appropriate? Are the methods described clearly and correctly?

Are the results presented clearly? Are statistical analyses appropriate?

Are the findings interpreted appropriately? Are limitations acknowledged?

Are the references relevant and up-to-date? Are all citations correct?

Is the manuscript well-written and clearly organized? Is the language appropriate?

Provide specific examples and page numbers when pointing out issues.

Focus on improving the manuscript rather than criticizing the authors.

Evaluate the work, not the authors. Avoid personal comments.

Clearly state your recommendation and the reasoning behind it.

Reviewer Recognition: Our top reviewers are recognized annually with certificates and are considered for editorial board positions.